good girls always say sorry

Good Girls Give, and Give, and Give Some More

“Rub my head, I’m tired,” my boyfriend whined, laying his head on my shoulder.

It was our third valentine’s day together and we were spending it in the emergency room.

Strep throat wrecked me for the second time in six months. Every time I swallowed, it was like thick shards of glass were slicing down my throat. I was exhausted. My fever had me oscillating between freezing my ass off and wanting to strip down to my skivvies.

But yes, Jeremy, let me rub your head because you’re tired. How silly of me not to comfort you in this, your time of need.

 I couldn’t help but wonder what was worse: his complaints or my fever?

As the lights flickered, time ticked on—stacking the hours on top of each other. Faded hearts and cliches about love floated in my heat-induced, foggy mind.

I felt like I was suffocating and I couldn’t tell if it was my swollen throat or this person taking up space on my shoulder. I needed to get out. I was done dealing with the pungent hospital smell… and this relationship.

I swallowed saliva filled with a thousand tiny knives, smiled weakly, and rubbed his head like a good girlfriend does.

My mother’s side of the family always tried to get together for birthdays. The birthday person got to choose where we’d go. Italian restaurants or steakhouses seemed to be the main picks.  

It was my ninth birthday, and I wanted Fresh Choice. It was all-you-can eat fanfare, made up of a giant salad bar that you glide through with lunch trays, choosing all kinds of goodies until you get to the register.

After you pay, you enter a large open space with stations filled with deliciousness. There was a pasta and pizza station, a dessert station with fresh fruit and frozen yogurt, and my most favorite part, the baked potato bar, with your choice of regular or sweet potato, and toppings and flavored butters galore.

These were all my favorite foods, so I decided it would be a fun place to have my birthday dinner.

“Who else is coming?” I asked hopefully as we sat down.

“Nobody really likes Fresh Choice, so it’s just the three of us tonight.” She said, shrugging her shoulders and sipping her iced tea.

My body deflated. I hung my head and moved my salad around my plate.

With a gentle elbow in my side, my friend grabbed my attention. Pointing at her plate with her fork and a mouth full of pasta, she gave me a big thumbs up. It made me feel better that she was enjoying herself.

I shook off my disappointment and decided to enjoy dinner anyway.

As I finished my tapioca, I made a mental note that next year, I would choose a steakhouse or something. After all, I wanted people to show up for me.

Always Useful, Always Giving

I didn’t think of myself as someone who gave too much. I thought of myself as someone who knew how to care for others. I paid attention. I remembered preferences. I learned how to make myself useful.

This made me popular in the way furniture is popular. I was dependable. I fit anywhere. People leaned on me without worrying whether I would move.

When I was exhausted or sick or quietly unraveling, it didn’t occur to me to stop. Wanting less felt like a failure of character. Saying no felt aggressive. Disappointing someone felt dangerous.

I didn’t ask myself what I wanted because wanting had never seemed relevant. Love, as I understood it, was about providing great service: always anticipating customer need.

Coughing up a lung, layering sweats and a hoodie as a fever chilled my body, I filled another wheelbarrow with heavy strips of sod. The folks at Home Depot had delivered it that morning and it needed to be dealt with immediately.

It didn’t matter that I had come down with the flu a few days before. My mother needed help and couldn’t be expected to do it herself. I told her I would help when she ordered it, and I had to stick to my word.

So, wheelbarrow after wheelbarrow, I moved the pallets of sod from the street, up the driveway, and around to our backyard where she filled in the dirt and clipped it to her liking.

I’d take brief breaks to drink tea or take flu medicine. It hadn’t reached my stomach, and I was grateful that I never felt more than nauseated.

“Come on, keep going. We need to finish this before the next rain comes,” my mother urged as I unpacked another load of grassy strips next to her.

I wiped my brow, leaving a trail of dirt on my face.

She looked up at me and laughed. “You’re a mess.”

I forced a smile and turned the wheelbarrow around to go and grab another pile.

“We’re nearly there!” She chirped at my back.

“Awesome!” I called back over my shoulder. We were only about halfway done. Each load was becoming more difficult, but at least she had started at the far end of the yard, so with every trip I didn’t have to go as far.

I knew after a few more hours of pushing myself, I would be able to shower and rest. That kept me trudging toward the finish line.

The Cost of Independence

The first time I told my mother no, it was over something small. I wanted to do Christmas morning with my boyfriend and our kids, instead of waking up at her house. I wanted to wake up in my own bed. I simply had other plans. Nothing dramatic. Nothing personal.

She reacted as if I’d canceled Christmas itself.

“But you promised that you’d wake up at my house!” she protested. “Who knows how many more holidays I’ll be able to get you to.” She insisted we had made these plans weeks before, when I knew we hadn’t.

After that, no was no longer just a word. It was evidence. Proof that I had changed. That I was selfish now and just wanted to take things away from her. She didn’t even recognize me anymore. Each refusal was treated like a character flaw, carefully documented and returned to me via text message, voicemail, or both.

I kept trying. I said no politely. I said it gently. I said it with explanation attached, to soften it, like apology notes. Nothing helped. The more I practiced having boundaries, the more disgusted she seemed by them.

“I’m losing my little girl,” she’d often say.

Then the letter arrived.

We were still speaking regularly, so the three-page handwritten envelope felt excessive. I don’t remember most of what it said anymore. I burned it, and time has been merciful in releasing pieces from my memory. But one line stuck: “It’s impossible to be a good mother with a daughter who is depressed and self-harms.”

I hadn’t accused her of anything. I didn’t need to. My boundaries did that for me.

When I told her I was moving six hours away in three months, the response escalated. The tone sharpened. The accusations multiplied. What I had framed as a necessary step toward my own life was treated as a personal attack.

After I moved, she got lawyers involved. I got threatening letters and eventually a court summons in an attempt to seek rights of my daughter.

By then, I understood the pattern well enough to name it, even if I was still shaking. Love, in my family, had always been conditional. It lasted exactly as long as I was compliant. The moment I stopped being useful, the cost of independence became very clear.  

 I still catch myself bracing for impact when I think I’ve disappointed someone. My shoulders tense. My stomach tightens.

 But then, nothing happens. No punishment arrives. No ledger produced.

 The silence that follows is no longer frightening. It’s just… quiet. I’m learning to recognize that feeling as peace. Protecting that peace isn’t an act of violence, despite what my mother may say.

Scroll to Top